
How can you tell fact from fiction on the Internet? Join Truthsquad, a community fact-checking experiment led by NewsTrust, in partnership with the Center for Public Integrity.
Together, we are developing a pro-am network to fact-check political claims during the 2012 elections — and aim to extend this small pilot site into a daily service by early 2012. By combining the Center’s newsroom of investigative journalists with our moderated crowd-sourcing service and contributions from our partners, we hope to provide daily fact-checks, as well as engage visitors as active participants to verify controversial claims. Read more about our plans on the NewsTrust blog and in these recent articles from The Atlantic and Nieman Journalism Lab.
For now, help fact-check controversial statements from politicians, media pundits and public figures on this pilot site. Our editors have picked some dubious quotes below. Are they TRUE or FALSE? Each quote has links to related evidence, which we invite you to review as well. You are welcome to change your answer anytime, as you find more factual evidence. Read more about our new fact-checking form on the NewsTrust blog.
To hear more about the Truthsquad experiment, check our report on PBS MediaShift about what we learned from our first pilots — as well as posts from GigaOM and Craig Newmark.
Our first pilot took place the week of August 2nd, 2010, with the help of our partners at the Poynter Institute and our advisors at FactCheck.org, and with the generous support of Omidyar Network and the MacArthur Foundation. Check our findings from this pilot on the NewsTrust blog — and the article from Read Write Web on NYTimes.com. At the end of 2010, we conducted a second pilot with MediaBugs.org and RegretTheError.com, focusing on statements from reporters or commentators (not politicians). In September 2011, we started a third pilot, to test our new fact-checking form and experiment with new types of claims.
Fact-check these Claims
Give Truthsquad a try. Click on one of the claims below.
(the most recent claims appear at the top of the list.)
-
Construction workers are "paying a higher tax rate than somebody pulling in $50 million a year."
By Barack Obama
-
"The federal government has not engaged in (border security) at all."
By Rick Perry
-
President Obama "went around the world and apologized for America"
By Mitt Romney, former governor (R-MA)
-
Maryland has "America's number one public school system."
By Maryland Gov. Martin O'Malley
-
"Social Security does not add one penny to the deficit."
By Sen. Richard Durbin (D-IL)
-
"Wisconsin ... is on track to have a budget surplus this year."
By Rachel Maddow, MSNBC
-
U.S. government "calculate[s] inflation without adding in the price of food and energy"
By Glenn Beck, Fox News
-
"Today there are more men and women out of work in America than there are people working in Canada."
By Mitt Romney, former governor (R-MA)
-
Fox News "never criticized George Bush for anything."
By Rachel Maddow, MSNBC
-
Obama is "on a trip to India that will cost 200 million dollars per day"
By Eric Bolling, Fox Business
-
"We're on a path to double the national debt in five years and triple it in ten."
By Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-KY)
-
"I've been outspent by my opponents every time I've run for Senate."
By Sen. Russ Feingold (D-WI)
-
Harry Reid "votes to give special tax breaks to illegal aliens."
By Sharron Angle (R-NV), U.S. Senate candidate
-
"Al Qaeda kills more Muslims than any other foreign imperial power."
By Irshad Manji, NYU scholar
-
"President Obama torpedoed the immigration reform bill."
By Ed Gillespie, former Republican Party Chair
-
[W]e used to be number one in the world in college graduation rates."
By Laura Tyson, Obama's economic advisor
-
Privatizing Social Security "would add trillions of dollars to our budget deficit"
By President Barack Obama
-
"87 million Americans will be forced out of their coverage" by Obama's health care plan
By Orrin Hatch, U.S. Senator
-
Decline in illegal immigration to U.S. "due to the recession," not Obama's enforcement
By Dick Morris, Fox News consultant
-
"Crime is totally out of control" in Phoenix
By Bill O'Reilly, Fox News
-
"Seniors guaranteed Medicare benefits will remain the same" under Obama's plan
By Kathleen Sebelius, U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services
-
"The 'Bush tax cuts' ... remain the single largest cause of America's structural deficit."
By Fareed Zakaria, Washington Post
-
CIA and Google investing in "a company that monitors the web... to predict the future."
By Noah Shachtman, Wired
-
Environmental impact of the oil spill "much less than everyone feared."
By Jacqueline Michel, Geochemist
-
"Warren Buffett called Greene’s scheme 'financial weapons of mass destruction.'"
By Kendrick Meek (D-FL), U.S. Senate candidate
-
"There’s no evidence of any significant concentration of oil that we haven’t accounted for."
By Jane Lubchenco, head of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
-
"Meek lobbied for big tobacco against children's healthcare."
By Jeff Greene (D-FL), U.S. Senate candidate
-
"Norton pushed the largest tax hike in Colorado history."
By Americans For Job Security
-
Obama's choice for budget chief received "$900,000 from Citigroup"
By Jim McElhatton, The Washington Times
-
"Middle-class families shouldn't pay higher taxes than millionaires"
By Barack Obama
Get started
To join the Truthsquad, follow these simple steps:
1. Pick a claim above
2. Check the links
3. Rate the claim
4. Write a note
For more instructions, read our FAQ or check the NewsTrust blog. Not a member yet? Sign up here.
Learn more
To learn more about fact checking and journalism, check out these guides:
- Tools of the Trade from FactCheckEd.org (check the video)
- PolitiFact’s Guide to Fact-checking from PolitiFact (video)
- Crap Detection 101 from Howard Rheingold (NewsTrust board member)
- Think Like A Journalist from Michael Bugeja (NewsTrust advisor)
Our goal for this project is to give you new tools for checking information on the web — and help us learn to separate facts from fiction, with the guidance of professionals.
What do you think?
How do you like Truthsquad? Email us with your comments and suggestions. If this pilot is successful, we are prepared to host more Truthsquads on an regular basis, with the help of our partners and members like you.
Support our work
NewsTrust is a nonprofit organization dedicated to helping people find quality news and information online. We are funded by foundation grants and donations from people like you — and are now actively fundraising to offer this service year-round, on a much wider scale than this pilot.
Donate today so we can host more Truthsquads in coming months.
Share This
JOIN THE TRUTHSQUAD
To participate in this pilot, please login or sign up below (if you haven’t already).
or sign up with NewsTrust »








