Ethanol: Feed a Person for a Year or Fill Up an SUV?

CounterPunch, AlterNet - by Robert Bryce - Mar. 5, 2007 (Opinion)
While politicians and Big Agriculture insist on casting the need for ethanol in terms of national security, the larger issue is a moral one: are we going to use our precious farmland to grow food, or use it to make motor fuel?
The ethanol scam just keeps getting more and more absurd. In January, three U.S. senators -- two Democrats, Tom Harkin of Iowa and Barack Obama of Illinois, along with Indiana Republican Richard Lugar -- introduced a bill that would promote the use of ethanol. It also mandates the use of more biodiesel and creates tax credits for the production of cellulosic ethanol. They called their bill the "American Fuels Act of 2007."

The most amazing part of ... More »
Review | Like | Submitted by Dale Penn
Featured Reviews
N1126433387_2982_thumb
3.3
by Dale Penn - Mar. 5, 2007 - See Full Review (12 answers)
Notes: This opinion piece had me until the last sentence. "...are we going to use our precious farmland to grow food, or are we going to subsidize the growth of an industry that turns food into a commodity, motor fuel, of which we already have an abundant supply?" Abundant supply? Did I miss a memo on peak oil?
Dale submitted this story.

Member_photo_thumb
3.5
by Mike LaBonte - Mar. 5, 2007 - See Full Review (13 answers)
Notes: Like many opinion articles, this one a light on evidence. Unfortunate since this particular subject has people arguing in both directions, and more hard facts are needed. Gives a very good overview of U.S. petroleum history. Accurate.

Silhoutte_sml
4.7
by Michael D. Lowe - Mar. 6, 2007 - See Full Review (13 answers)
Notes: This well sourced & the authors conclusions are in plain site. A bit inflammatory in style maybe but still solid. There are reports coming out of Mexico that the lack of seed corn caused by US corn producers snapping up the supply has caused the price of corn to soar. So there are already some very real effects being felt. Most discussions of crop fuel sources do not take into account the full cost of production. Phosphate fertilizer run off, water table depletion, lack of ... More »

More Reviews
Silhoutte_sml
3.6
by Nick Pollitt - Mar. 5, 2007 - See Full Review (6 answers)

Silhoutte_sml
4.1
by John Ferriere - Mar. 8, 2007 - See Full Review (6 answers)

Silhoutte_sml
5.0
by Jami Dwyer - Mar. 5, 2007 - See Full Review (1 answer)

Tags Help
Topics Business, Sci/Tech, World | Energy, Environment
Research Help
Search Sites Google | Yahoo | Technorati | Wikipedia | del.icio.us
Stats Help
Editorial Help
Submitted by Submitted by Dale Penn - Mar 5, 2007 - 7:59 AM PST
Reviewed by Dale Penn (review), Jami Dwyer (review), Nick Pollitt (review), Mike LaBonte (review), Michael D. Lowe (review), John Ferriere (review)
Edited by Dale Penn - Mar 5, 2007 - 8:02 AM PST
No quotes yet. Please review this story to add some!
No comments yet. Please review this story to add yours!
Tools

To:


Separate email addresses with commas.
25 recipients max.

Note:


(Beta) Ratings
Our Rating
3.8
(very good)
6 reviews

Quality
3.8

Accuracy
5.0

Balance
3.0

Context
4.0

Facts
3.7

Fairness
3.2

Information
3.8

Sourcing
3.8

Style
4.0

Popularity
3.7

Recommendation
4.0

Credibility
3.4

# Reviews
3.0

# Views
2.6

# Likes
1.0

# Emails
1.0


How our ratings work