Israeli Scholar Disputes Founding Myth

In When and How Was the Jewish People Invented?, Dr. Sand, an expert on European history at the University of Tel Aviv, says the Diaspora was largely a myth – that the Jews were never exiled en masse from the Holy Land and that many European Jewish populations converted to the faith centuries later.

Thus, Sand argues, many of today’s Israelis who emigrated from Europe after World War II have little or no genealogical connection to the land. ... Full Story »

Posted by Dwight Rousu

See All Reviews »

To:


Separate email addresses with commas.
25 recipients max.

Note:

Review

N1126433387_2982_thumb
3.9
by Dale Penn - Apr. 12, 2009

I know next to nothing about this subject. The blog post comes off as a scholarly work worthy of serious consideration. It makes me want to read Sand's book. I haven't read other NT commentary as I write this, so I'm eager to see what others think. I plan to forward this to a number of Jewish friends who may have a clearer understanding of the subject than I. This sense of wanting to know more tends to make me believe that this is in fact good journalism.

Here is the response from a friend who is very involved in the Anti-Defamation League: "I cannot speak about the history but to me it is meaningless. First of all, anyone who was close enough to have had a conversation with Arafat is suspect to me. Second, Israel was granted the right to exist by the UN, not by force. Immediately thereafter they were attacked by the Arabs. Their legitimacy comes from this not whether or not God gave it to them or the origins of the Diaspora."

(18 answers)

Dale's Rating

Overall
3.9

Good
from 18 answers
Quality
4.0
Facts
4.0
Fairness
3.0
Information
5.0
Insight
4.0
Sourcing
4.0
Style
5.0
Balance
3.0
Context
4.0
Depth
4.0
Enterprise
4.0
Expertise
4.0
Originality
4.0
Relevance
4.0
Transparency
3.0
Popularity
3.5
Recommendation
4.0
Credibility
3.0
More How our ratings work »