Thoughtful perspective on America's role in Afghanistan, from a former CIA analyst for thirty years. The author reports on a recent RAND-sponsored discussion of Afghanistan, featuring speakers such as Zbigniew Brzezinski, James Dobbins and Sen. Carl Levin. This provides a wide range of viewpoints about the tough decision faced by the Obama Adminstration about the U.S. presence in Afghanistan - including a timely quote from Kipling about 'The White Man's Burden'.

A real good piece Afghanistan from Ray McGovern. The title of his OpEd suggested he is well-read, insightful, and enterprising. I like the way he interpret things, and presented the facts backed by direct quotes and interviews. He presented a global picture. I've no more words to praise him. Well done Mr McGovern.

Must reading for Obama, that'ssfor sure. And remarkable rubbish from James Dobbins who "warns" that Iran, Russia and China might get involved in Afghanistan if the US gets out. In fact, Iran's assistance is essential if minimum stability is to be achieved. Russia and China need to help also, so the US can drop back into a much less prominent role.

McGovern tells the whole story. He covers both sides, admits his bias, and defends it with facts.