A controversial story, one I have trouble rating. DeYoung absolutely could have written this more carefully. I'm surprised at how many seemingly unchecked quotes the Post allowed Hoh, and I question how much of his back story is relevant to his resignation. Nevertheless, an important piece with plenty of information about its key figure.

Informative article about former Marine Matthew Hoh, who resigned from the Foreign Service to protest the war in Afghanistan. This report provides good information about his background and career, including comments from U.S. officials involved in this incident (though none of his previous employers, colleagues or family members are cited in this profile). A few more independent sources and perspectives would be helpful to provide more context about Hoh and the circumstances that ... More »

This is an example of superb journalism. The story presents the facts of the matter, complete with a link (online version) to the actual resignation letter, which is well worth reading, and puts those facts in context with a very compelling account of the experiences that shaped the military life and attitudes of Capt. Hoh. Hoh is presented here as a sincere, thoughtful, brave and resourceful soldier and employee of the Foreign Service. The content of his letter supports what the ... More »

DeYoung gives us a well written article about Hoh's experience, his reputation, and his views on Afghanistan. For multiple sourcing, many other people have similar view in other articles.

This is a well written story describing Matthew Hoh, his background, his experiences, his observations regarding rural Afghanistan and the reasons that he provides for resigning. While there are short statements of praise from those that disagree with Hoh's assessment, the focus is on Hoh, not analysis of his views. Viewed in that light, is is a very good story.

I posted this story early this morning under the CBS news pickup due to the difficulty of reading and referencing the WaPO site if you are not an online member...read the Greenwald article fro back up

Outstanding, thoughtful account of a dramatically important action by a courageous former Marine who has resigned from the US Foreign Service because of his disillusionment with US policy in Afghanistan. Extensive quotes from Matthew Hoh, other diplomatic and military officers give a fully-formed portrait of one man's careful analysis and evaluation of the situation in Afghanistan. A "Must Read" for anyone who wants to understand what is happening and why.

This is a chilling account of what the Obama administration is up against in Afghanistan. It's especially credible because of Hoh's impressive military experience and carefully considered reasons for resigning. In crisp senttences, the writer draws together all the salient information about how seriously Hoh's action has been taken by the administration.

An informative article that conveys both the character and experience of Matthew Hoh and the situation on the ground in Afghanistan. What the article does not provide is adequate context: Why did the United States, after 9/11, decide that invading Afghanistan and deposing the Taliban was so essential? And, if it was so essential eight years ago, why is leaving now a viable option?

This is a reasonablely well done article. One point missed is the difference from those who are in the trench and and the higher officers who know that they may loose troops but can stiil win.

This thoughtful and revealing article tells the story of U.S. official Matt Hoh, and it presents his assessment of the war in Afghanistan. As an insider's account, the article offers a sincere and quite important contribution to the current debate about Afghanistan.