Ward puts the Montcoal disaster in a larger context by examining mining law passed after the last major US disaster, also in WV, at Sago. He interviews Davitt McAteer and Tony Oppegard, former MSHA officials who come from a safety, rather than industry background (unlike subsequent appointees) He outlines how the WV communications and tracking legislation falls short of MSHA requirements. My favorite quote is from Oppegard, along with Ward's writing surrounding it. (See the quote I've included. The final bill passed was not as strong as originally submitted and that Labor Committee chair George Miller has slacked off in making improvements since a president from his own party was elected. A small quibble: the story would ... More »

In a short space, this article analyzes underlying causes of the mine disaster in Montcoal WV on 4/5/10. It is excellent in 3 ways: the historical context it provides, the writer's detailed knowledge of the geography & people, the high quality of experts used as sources. Unlike many of the national level journalists who are coming in to cover this story, Ken Ward has the advantage of local & regional knowledge -- so his article distills many complex questions about a) quality of safety regulations (do they match up well with the real technical & human dangers) and b) the quality of enforcement. His depth of background knowledge allows him to focus on most important issues & best sources with seasoned expertise. This shows ... More »

A very solid analysis of the conditions leading to the recent fatal Montcoal accident. Reported by a staff writer from an area newspaper, the Charleston (WV) Gazette. Asks all the right questions, which will hopefully lead to answers and opportunities for real, substantial mine safety reform.

This article is particularly valuable for readers unfamiliar with the safety issues which plague the mining industry, and who may not recall details of previous disasters nor corrective measures which were attempted. The writing is clear, concise, and vividly describes which factors likely contributed to this latest disaster.