Naomi Isler

Founding Member (since April 2006)
Help

I have never been a journalist. However, at various times I have been in a position to know the 'true facts' of a newsworthy situation. I then watched both the newsmaker spin on and the media interpretations (for the lack of a better word) of those facts. Different planets, on too many occasions.

About Naomi Help
Occupation: retired
Favorites Help
Topics: World, U.S.
Contact Info Help
Email:
Last Visit: Nov 19, 2009 - 1:41 PM PST
Last Edit: Apr 11, 2008 - 5:53 PM PDT
| |

To:


Separate email addresses with commas.
25 recipients max.

Note:

Activity

Show all | Reviews | Posts | Likes | Comments
Naomi reviewed this story - Nov 9, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.0

This is good because it highlights the conflicts that first and second generation immigrants have always faced. Honor killing is a fact of life in several countries - we ignore it 'there'. The issue goes beyond womens' rights; it's how much of the old country culture can families hang onto in the new world, and how does the older generation handle the fact that it's role isn't the same here as there. Honor killing is an extreme case - but every new group needs to somehow resolve ... More »

That said, I hope the guy gets life! Wonder what his wife thinks. The son and brother who is quoted almost seems to feel that she deserved it?

See Full Review » (6 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.6
Naomi reviewed this story - Nov 9, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.0

Yes, it describes the effects of an apparently scientific survey of biased media on people. How original!

Good grief! Has anyone read the history of Europe between 1933 and 1945? Has anyone ever heard of 'the big lie"? Why do we keep rediscovering ... More »

See Full Review » (5 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.9
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Nov 5, 2009
Naomi's Rating
3.8

It may be one of the better articles analyzing what the 2009 election means.

I really feel that the NY23rd is a better indication of what people are thinking on national issues. Yes, both of the gubernatorial elections ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.8
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Nov 4, 2009
Naomi reviewed this story - Oct 30, 2009
Naomi's Rating
3.7

I'm not sure what this is trying to prove. Assuming that the donations and activities are part of a will or other legal document, what is the problem.

But I have to draw the line at voting! I know it's been done (did Karzai think of that?) but that does cross a line!

See Full Review » (5 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.0
Naomi reviewed this story - Oct 19, 2009
Naomi's Rating
3.0

It just states the fairly obvious. I suppose the fact that Newsweek runs it is significant.

There used to be a 'fairness' doctrine forradio and tv , abandoned in some deregulatory era. This allowed the polarization we see now. However, in ... More »

See Full Review » (5 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.5
Naomi posted this story - Oct 8, 2009
Naomi reviewed this story - Oct 3, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.8

History is always useful, especially for those who haven't lived through some of it. What the article omits is how the country got out of the fear induced overreactions. And it omits the role of the Democrats in fearmongering in the so called Solid South.

See Full Review » (4 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.1
Naomi reviewed this story - Sep 22, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.4
See Full Review » (4 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.3
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Sep 21, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.0

It tries to summarize the inputs to Obama's decision making process on Afghanistan - and makes an assumption about the aims of the war. It ignores the idea that Afghanistan has never really had a strong central government.

And apparently the international community is stuck with a government that steals everything so blatantly that it doesn't realize you aren't ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.0
Naomi reviewed this story - Sep 21, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.0
See Full Review » (5 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.0
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Sep 21, 2009
Naomi reviewed this story - Sep 20, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.1

The report combines interviews, reviews of reports, opinion, personal stories, etc. It speaks to a real problem that keeps being ignored.

It doesn't deal with pollution of rivers and other waterways. And it's one more indictment of agribusiness, though smaller operators can also cause ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.7
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Sep 15, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.1

It points to what the author believes is an increasing tendency toward self-censorship because of perceived threats - either terrorist or economic. And the author believes this is something new. She doesn't mention the Obama Administration caving in to a right wing talk person!

It's not new, it's been going on - at least in my memory - since the 1940s.

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.1
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Sep 15, 2009
Naomi reviewed this story - Sep 12, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.4

Categories like 'factual' don't really fit this piece. It's a moving exploration of the relationship between foreign correspondents, and the local reporter-factotums without whom they probably couldn't report. It has a broader context - the vlllagers who 'cooperate' with will intentioned nation builders, and who are killed when someone decides that the nation has been built - and the builders leave.

Dith Pran, anyone??

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.2
Naomi reviewed this story - Sep 10, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.9

This is an interesting take on health problems which I, at least, haven't seen before. And it forecasts an interesting future political battle. Agricultural policy has been another political 'third rail' for many years now - this should be fun to watch.

And agricultural policy makes most peoples' eyes glaze over. Among problems not noted in the article: agribusiness is making a lot of land ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.5
Naomi reviewed this story - Sep 8, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.3

It's good in that it pinpoints the role of Fox News and the radical Right in bringing down a White House Advisor - and faults the left for letting it happen without much protest. It is not really a rant, but a challenge.

I refer people to a Bill Moyers broadcast of several months ago in which he played pieces from various right wing commentators - and it was scary. ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.3
Naomi reviewed this story - Sep 4, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.1

It's a well thought out piece on economic theory and theorists, probably of more interest to economists than 'lay people'. Lurking in the unstated background is the question of who presidents and other policy makers listen to, and why.

Isn't economics 'the dismal science"??

See Full Review » (6 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.3
Naomi posted this story - Aug 19, 2009
Naomi reviewed this story - Aug 16, 2009
Naomi's Rating
3.9

It shows some of the problems one congressman is having. Readers need to extrapolate.

Somehow what is or is not in the health care reform proposals is not being conveyed accurately by media. And given the number and omnipresence of ... More »

See Full Review » (6 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.7
Naomi reviewed this story - Aug 16, 2009
Naomi's Rating
3.8

It's a somewhat scary view of what may really be going on. Sourcing seems plentiful, if mostly anonymous, but there is a quote from Holbrooke. I

What it implies is that the Talibn is a lot more powerful and entrenched then most Western governments and media sources are willing to admit. That ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.7
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Aug 10, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.2

This summarizes in one place a lot of the individual problems often covered by media.

What's good is also not so great - why hasn't such a summary appeared before? Or has it appeared and been ignored?

See Full Review » (6 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.7
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Aug 10, 2009
Naomi reviewed this story - Aug 3, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.1

Am I the only person who is reminded of what was going on in Moscow in the 1930s?? And those trials did not lead to overthrow of that government - ... More »

See Full Review » (6 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.9
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 31, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.0

It seems to be n accurate summary of what is happening to some Congressmen. What I don't think ti answers is the question of whether theaw are fringe people, or people representing something near a mainstream.

See Full Review » (4 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.0
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 31, 2009
Naomi reviewed this story - Jul 13, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.2

The column advocates for one possibility for funding health care reform - which probably is not going to happen. It ignores the issue of cost control, which is probably the real issue.

See Full Review » (9 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.0
Naomi reviewed this story - Jul 13, 2009
Naomi's Rating
3.9

I guess this stands in contrast to the other stimulus story.

See Full Review » (10 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.7
Naomi reviewed this story - Jul 12, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.5

It gives the view of a Westerner who has considerable experience in and presumably understanding of the Middle East. And it's a different view than appears in most of the Western media.

This tries to deflate Western wishful thinking about happenings in Iran.

See Full Review » (10 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.3
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 12, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.0

The story seems to be based on personal interview and observation. It shows a major weakness in Western efforts in a place they don't quite understand.

I think this is called facts on the ground.

See Full Review » (12 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.9
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 12, 2009
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 11, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.6

The report discusses in some depth a problem of technology vs. privacy. The RFID chip apparently makes everybody vulnerable to hacking, is impossible not to carry if a person drives, or presumably has a government id in place of a license, or travels out of the country.

Apparently this is done in the name of security. Whose security??? I just renewed my driver's license - what a comforting feeling!

See Full Review » (12 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.4
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 11, 2009
Naomi reviewed this story - Jul 11, 2009
Naomi's Rating
3.9

Does no one remember during the Regan recession when the then remedies didn't seem to be working that the Republican mantra was 'give the medicine ... More »

See Full Review » (9 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 2.8
Naomi reviewed this story - Jul 10, 2009
Naomi's Rating
3.8

The question is does the piece cover the event or cover the media coverage. It uses three (?) media sources to show somewhat different focuses on the violence, and to try to build a more complete story.

For years everyone has focussed on the Tibetans to the exclusion of other minorities in China. Now another group emerges with similar issues. ... More »

See Full Review » (10 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.2
Naomi reviewed this story - Jul 10, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.0

I guess it's quality journalism, reporting on less-than-quality happenings. Yes, happenings. What have they all been thinking - or smoking?

And we wonder why people hold government in contempt!

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.0
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 10, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.0

This looks at an often ignored topic - problems with defense department contracts and the armaments produced by them. The article does cite some positive opinion of the plane's performance, but emphasizes its downside(s). The political implications are explored, too.

Is Saxbe Chambliss (who ran that horrible campaign against Max Cleland) one of the senators who thinks health care reform will be too costly??

See Full Review » (7 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.0
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 9, 2009
Naomi reviewed this story - Jul 9, 2009
Naomi's Rating
4.6

This is a good exposition of the concept of 'rationing' , and how our current system actually does 'ration' care.

See Full Review » (5 answers)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 4.3
(Beta)

Levels & Stats

Member LevelHelp
3.3 avg.
3.3 avg.
Activity
5.0 avg.
Experience
3.1 avg.
Ratings
3.7 avg.
Transparency
2.1 avg.
Validation
3.0 avg.

StatsHelp
Story Reviews
400
Number of Raters
54
Ratings Received
203
Number of Comments
1
Ratings Given
1
Story Answers
2,397

Member Ratings

Ratings given by Naomi (1) Help



Ratings received by Naomi (see all 203) Help

More ratings »
(NEW)

Naomi's Widget

Add this widget to your site »