While the article takes a look at what may be a bigger issue behind the Fort Hood shooting, it is not in depth and does not get enough quotations from different stakeholders; this leaves it incomplete and not as strong as it could be. Absolutely relevant.
Kristin Gorski
Founding Member (since May 2008)I joined NewsTrust because I wanted to experience its media literacy tools. I also believe that a healthy democracy needs a media-literate populace, so I wanted to participate in NewsTrust and increase my own media literacy. As I participate, I'm thinking of possible wider applications of media literacy tools for the general population and for students in classroom settings.
To:
Separate email addresses with commas.
25 recipients max.
Note:
A thoughtful analysis of how the GOP seems to embracing racism and anti-semitism as part ideologies. It's well-reasoned and topical, using congresspeople's own words to support assertions.
An intelligent, witty treatment of a sign of the times: being consumed by technology-based tasks while piloting a large passenger plane, and forgetting when to land. Solid sociological context. Great insights from experts.
The report starts off clear with an analysis and sourced report. Then Olbermann cuts to the most convoluted, emotional segment of the interview where the subjects involved start fighting and threatening each other. I don't think that a heated disagreement (that actually seems personal) can be spun out to predict the crumbling of the entire GOP. For an analysis to be more useful, it needs to be grounded much more in statistics and verified sources.
There was no organized narrative thread to the report. I was confused by a series of images, audio clips, and historical quotations linked together without any grounding in a larger context. It doesn't seem like a news report, as it's not reporting any news. It was a list of complaints about a variety of non-connected media items, and in the end, it didn't make much sense. This is an opinion piece, but not very well expressed. The reporter's sarchasm and anger underpins everything he says.
I've never watched Glenn Beck's show before. It was interesting to see it and reflect on what people say about it. (I thought there would be more ... More »
Original insights and careful analysis of the consequences of possible health care reform bill(s) passing. Links out to other articles support the writer's points and provide additional information to interested readers. Certainly puts the AHIP's recent report about rising health insurance costs into proper perspective.
Features a lot of direct quotations from the Senate vote which show how historic many think this legislation will be. Interesting narrative but not much context or statistics to frame it.
Clearly written and includes a lot of relevant background regarding what's been happening in Senate negotiations to get the bill where it is today.
A good analysis of what's currently happening with Republicans in Congress in the face of health care reform. Some historical context is included. However, not many Republicans are interviewed to get their point of view on why they vote the way they do.
-
Insurance Mandates Draw Flak From Both Sides
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.0
The story seems incomplete here. While I clearly get some information about the CBO's importance to the health care reform bill process, I don't get a comprehensive answer to the title's question: "What about your wallet?" We all know that there will be hidden or unforeseen costs, but without solid facts and figures, I don't know what it really means.
That’s partly why House Speaker Nancy Pelosi on Thursday asked the CBO to score three versions of a government-run public option. It is part of ... More »
Blends a bit of history with current politics through the lens of former Republican Senator Bob Dole's change of heart on health care reform. Accurately states what is at stake -- for reform, the country and both Democratic and Republican parties. Great context.
Highly original, from the basic question underlying the piece ("How long would it take for someone to read the entire health care bill?") to the answers from various experts. Makes some relevant points about the democratic and legislative process on the way. Well done and enjoyable to read.
An interesting profile of Senator Olympia Snowe (R) of Maine. Relevant -- no one knows how she'll vote on the Senate's health care reform bill, and her vote could be the swing for either party. Well written.
This interactive, well-sourced column features checks of statements from across the political spectrum, including viral email, TV ads and movie directors in addition to politicians. The Truth-o-meter graphic gives a general sense of where the statements fall, and links underneath go to other pages which provide the big picture. Nicely done. A good resource (which goes on for pages and can be continually updated).
-
Truth-O-Meter: Statements on Health Care
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.8
This interactive, well-sourced column features checks of statements from across the political spectrum, including viral email, TV ads and movie directors in addition to politicians. The Truth-o-meter graphic gives a general sense of where the statements fall, and links underneath go to other pages which provide the big picture. Nicely done. A good resource (which goes on for pages and can be continually updated).
An important angle to feature about the ongoing health care debate. Needs additional facts and viewpoints to make it more informative.
A quick, accurate, up-to-the-minute look at a major development in the steps towards passing a health care reform bill.
This article highlights the results of an important study on how location affects quality of health care received, but it does little else. Including takes from key stakeholders would help complete the picture of these statistics and provide needed context.
-
For best healthcare, location matters: study
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.4





Only 20% of Americans ID themselves as Republicans (the lowest point in history), says Chris Kofinis, the Democratic strategist. If this is true, ... More »