The reporting here is excellent, but I'm concerned with the background information. Americans have been involved in this sort of proxy arming before (in the '80's), and the consequences were grave. The article mentions this, but doesn't give concerns their due. For instance, there's no comment from a critic of this strategy.
Kaizar Campwala
Founding Member (since April 2006)
I am the Associate Editor at NewsTrust, where I coordinate editorial and community activities on the site. Prior to joining NewsTrust, I was a communications technology consultant to the City of New York. I earned a A.B. from Brown University in Political Science, with a focus on American politics and public access to information.
Why NewsTrust?
There is too much good journalism in the world to sit back and allow mediocre reporting to be uncritically consumed. As trust in a fragmenting news media declines, new tools are needed to help people sift through the noise and find the news that will responsibly and objectively inform them about world events. By urging readers to review the articles they are reading, NewsTrust gives them a stake in thinking critically about the news they consume. The site challenges readers to question their preconceived notions about a particular news source while allowing them to express their criticisms in a quantifiable way.
Del.icio.us Bookmarks
To:
Separate email addresses with commas.
25 recipients max.
Note:
An interesting story in concept, this piece doesn't really do a good job of forecasting what how we can expect the debate to change because of the holidays.
-
Thrust and Parry on the Senate Floor (Pending)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 1.0
-
Talk of new jobs bill triggers interest-group lobbying push (Pending)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 1.0
-
Is There Such a Thing as Agro-Imperialism?
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 2.0
There's good information here about all that's on the legislative agenda. It's also good that it's not a straight -- he said, she story, but includes some independent analysis.
-
Obama Nominates Pesticide Executive to Be Chief Agricultural Negotiator in the Office of the US Trade Representative
| Share
This interview features an advocate who is actively opposed to GMO and pesticides. To give a more rounded picture of this issue, Goodman should have included a statement from a good government expert (to address the conflict of interest) issue and a statement from the administration.
-
Is the meaning of hajj being lost?
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 2.0
-
working-women-husbands-housework
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 1.9
Thanks Lynn,
It’s great to read about research before it’s been sensationalized and decontextualized by the MSM. To that point, one of my favorite resources of science reporting, on Climate Change and other issues, is the More »
-
November 13, 2009 (Pending)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 1.0
-
Transcript of "The Good Doctor" (November 13, 2009) (Pending)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 1.0
Derek,
You raise a very good question. The simple answer seems to be that key players (politicians, interest groups, Washington media) have already staked out their positions, and current debate isn’t about good policy, but rather who will compromise how much from their ... More »
-
-- Please fill in story title -- (Pending)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 1.0
Morgenson makes a decent case that lobbying money bought home builders huge sums of Federal money, that perhaps they didn't deserve. This piece needs comment by more sources.
Health-care reform is about more than covering more Americans and controlling costs. It’s also about quality. Repairing health care requires “delivery-system ... More »
-
Is It Time for Malpractice Reform?
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.7
-
Major Hasan's E-Mail: 'I Can't Wait to Join You' in Afterlife (Pending)
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 1.0
-
Welcome to the Vast Right-Wing Conspiracy
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 2.6
-
U.S. resetting its relationship with Karzai
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.8
-
The $100 Million Health Care Vote?
See All NT Reviews » NT Rating: 3.2
Unfortunately, there's not a lot of depth to this interview. Merley mostly speaks in talking points and generalities.
This is an important story that shows a revolving door exists not just on the industry side of political lobbying, but also on the issue side. It's interesting that the author quotes a 'opposing' lobbyist, but didn't get comment from a liberal lobby reform advocate.





Obama Nominates Pesticide Executive to Be Chief Agricultural Negotiator in the Office of the US Trade Representative
This story conflates two issues: that the nominee is a lobbyist, and that he may have big-agriculture biases. From the standpoint of holding the administration accountable, the former seems like the more important issue. However, Goodman and her guest focus on the latter.